Archaeology

Archaeological Impact Assessment Guidelines

Appendix D

Checklist of Criteria for Pre-Contact Site Evaluation

Scientific Significance

  1. Does the site contain evidence which may substantively enhance understanding of culture history, culture process, and other aspects of local and regional prehistory?
    • internal stratification and depth
    • chronologically sensitive cultural items
      materials for absolute dating
    • association with ancient landforms
    • quantity and variety of tool type
    • distinct intra-site activity areas
    • tool types indicative of specific socio-economic or religious activity
    • cultural features such as burials, dwellings, hearths, etc.
    • diagnostic faunal and floral remains
    • exotic cultural items and materials
    • uniqueness or representativeness of the site
    • integrity of the site
  2. Does the site contain evidence which may be used for experimentation aimed at improving archaeological methods and techniques?
    • monitoring impacts from artificial or natural agents
    • site preservation or conservation experiments
    • data recovery experiments
    • sampling experiments
    • intra-site spatial analysis
  3. Does the site contain evidence which can make important contributions to paleoenvironmental studies?
    • topographical, geomorphological context
    • depositional character
    • diagnostic faunal, floral data
  4. Does the site contain evidence which can contribute to other scientific disciplines such as hydrology, geomorphology, pedology, meteorology, zoology, botany, forensic medicine, and environmental hazards research, or to industry including forestry and commercial fisheries?

Return to Top

Public Significance

  1. Does the site have potential for public use in an interpretive, educational or recreational capacity?
    • integrity of the site
    • technical and economic feasibility of restoration and development for public use
    • visibility of cultural features and their ability to be easily interpreted
    • accessibility to the public
    • opportunities for protection against vandalism
    • representativeness and uniqueness of the site
    • aesthetics of the local setting
    • proximity to established recreation areas
    • present and potential land use
    • land ownership and administration
    • legal and jurisdictional status
    • local community attitude toward development
  2. Does the site receive visitation or use by tourists, local residents or school groups?

Return to Top

Ethnic Significance

  1. Does the site presently have traditional, social or religious importance to a particular group or community?
    • ethnographic or ethnohistoric reference
    • documented local community recognition or, and concern for, the site

Return to Top

Economic Significance

  1. What value of user-benefits may be placed on the site?
    • visitors' willingness-to-pay
    • visitors' travel costs

Next Page >>